CO129-136 - Sir MacDonnell - 1869 [1-3] — Page 217

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

STRONA SAARENGANA MAY

213

It seems however very unfortunate not merely that such a precedent should be established allowing an illegal proclamation to be left unaltered, on the assurance of the Viceroy that such Proclamation meant something different from that which it stated, but that the objections raised by the Governor of Hong Kong affected by that Proclamation should be regarded as disposed of by explanations what Governor... ever communicated to ...

19. I further consider that a very grave omission pervades all the explanations given by the Colonial and Sir Rutherford Alcock relative to the Proclamation of the Viceroy. They both dilate at length on the right of the Chinese Government to protect itself against loss of Revenue by smuggling. No one denies that principle, but under a doctrine that secures general assent, Her Majesty's Minister at Peking observes that the very unusual manner in which that protection is sought to be secured, namely by compelling vessels when leaving a Foreign Port whither they are not bound to go to a certain port for the purpose of there paying a duty which should by the general usage of civilized nations only become payable on arrival of the dutiable articles at their destination.

10. I consider that whatever be the right of the Chinese to protect their Revenue against smuggling their "modus operandi" effecting that object has limits which are determined...

Edit History

2026-05-20 02:47:55 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
STRONA SAARENGANA MAY 213 It seems however very unfortunate not merely that such a precedent should be established allowing an illegal proclamation to be left unaltered, on the assurance of the Viceroy that such Proclamation meant something different from that which it stated, but that the objections raised by the Governor of Hong Kong affected by that Proclamation should be regarded as disposed of by explanations what Governor... ever communicated to ... 19. I further consider that a very grave omission pervades all the explanations given by the Colonial and Sir Rutherford Alcock relative to the Proclamation of the Viceroy. They both dilate at length on the right of the Chinese Government to protect itself against loss of Revenue by smuggling. No one denies that principle, but under a doctrine that secures general assent, Her Majesty's Minister at Peking observes that the very unusual manner in which that protection is sought to be secured, namely by compelling vessels when leaving a Foreign Port whither they are not bound to go to a certain port for the purpose of there paying a duty which should by the general usage of civilized nations only become payable on arrival of the dutiable articles at their destination. 10. I consider that whatever be the right of the Chinese to protect their Revenue against smuggling their "modus operandi" effecting that object has limits which are determined...
Baseline (Original)
STRONA SAARENGANA MAY 213 It seems however very unfortunate not merely 1 that such a precedent should be established مت allowing www i illegal proclamation to be left unaltered, on the apuance of the Vicelloy that such Proclamation mecent something different from that which it stated, flout that the alejections raised by the Govemer Jofa شه Butish backony affected by that Proclamation should be regarded us disposed Lof by explanations What Governor. mever communicated to 19. I further consider that سات very grave omision pervades les all the explanations given by the bonaul and Sir thutherford Absock relative to the Proclamation of the Vicethay. They both dilate it length on the right of the bhinese Government to protect itself cegin? against lefs of Revenue by smuggling. No one denies that principle, but, under of a doctime that secures general efsent, cover Her Majesty's Mernister at Pettin prepes crer the very unusual over manner in which that protection is sought to be secured, namely by compelling repels when leaving a Foreign Port whither they are not bountry to go to a bound for the purpose of there paying or duty which should by the general usage of civilized nations only become payable anival of the dutiable articles at their destination. 10. on I consider that whatever be the right of the Chinese to protect their Prevenue against their "modus operandi effecting smuggling their "Modus that object has limits which "for are determined
2026-05-20 02:47:55 · Baseline
View content

STRONA SAARENGANA MAY

213

It

seems

however

very unfortunate not merely

1 that such a precedent should be established

مت

allowing

www

i

illegal proclamation to be

left unaltered, on the apuance of the Vicelloy that such Proclamation mecent something different from that which it stated,

flout that the alejections raised by the Govemer

Jofa

شه

Butish backony affected by that Proclamation should be regarded us disposed

Lof by explanations

What Governor.

mever

communicated to

19. I further consider that

سات

very grave omision pervades

les all the explanations given by the bonaul and Sir thutherford Absock relative to the Proclamation of the Vicethay. They both dilate it length on the right of the bhinese Government to protect itself

cegin?

against lefs of Revenue by smuggling. No one denies that principle, but, under of a doctime that secures general efsent,

cover

Her Majesty's Mernister at Pettin prepes crer

the

very

unusual

over

manner in which that

protection is sought to be secured, namely

by compelling repels when leaving a Foreign Port whither they are not

bountry to go

to a

bound for the purpose of there paying or

duty which should by the general usage of civilized nations only become payable

anival of the dutiable articles at their

destination.

10.

on

I consider that whatever be the right

of the Chinese to protect their Prevenue against their "modus operandi effecting smuggling their "Modus

that object has limits which

"for

are determined

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.